Topic: GS2 – Social Justice, GS3 – Indian Economy – Inclusive growth This topic is crucial for UPSC as it pertains to socioeconomic issues, governance, and policy-making in India’s development agenda. |
Context: |
● The article discusses the growing debate on inequality and wealth redistribution in India, emphasizing the need for inclusive growth policies and increased welfare spending. |
Debate on Inequality and Wealth Redistribution
- The Congress party’s Nyay Patra manifesto has sparked a debate on inequality and wealth concentration, amplified by the Prime Minister’s comments.
- Rising inequality in India, evident from the World Inequality database, necessitates addressing the societal costs of unequal growth.
Welcome Election Issue
- The emergence of inequality as an election issue is crucial, highlighting the failure of trickle-down economics and the need for inclusive growth policies.
- Social media discussions largely focus on direct redistribution measures, given India’s low tax-GDP ratio and regressive taxation structure.
Low Welfare Spending
- Welfare spending in India remains low, particularly in sectors like health, education, and employment generation, hindering inclusive development.
- Despite targets set by policies like the National Health Policy, actual spending falls short, exacerbating inequality.
Questioning Growth Patterns
- The nature of growth in India, characterised by jobless growth and stagnant wages, necessitates a shift towards employment-centred development.
- Governments must prioritise job creation through filling vacancies, expanding public services, and improving job quality for better human development outcomes.
Role of Government in Job Creation
- Direct job creation efforts by the government, especially in sectors like health and education, can address unemployment and improve human development indicators.
- Employment-centred growth requires policies supporting small and medium enterprises, skill training, and women’s participation in the labour market.
Conclusion
- Addressing inequality requires a shift from profit-centric growth to employment-centred development, emphasising job creation and equitable access to services.
- Government policies must prioritise inclusive growth measures to reduce inequality and promote sustainable development.
Growing inequality in India |
Some important data: ● Top 10% of India’s populace owns 77% of national wealth; wealthiest 1% controls 53%. ● Income inequality: Top 10% and top 1% command 57% and 22% of national income, while bottom 50% share 13%. ● Tax burden: Bottom 50% contributes 64% of GST revenue, contrasting with 4% from top 10%. ● Healthcare accessibility: Healthcare costs plunge 63 million Indians into poverty yearly. ● Food security: 74% can’t afford healthy diets, 39% lack nutrient-adequate food. ● Hunger and malnutrition: India’s Global Hunger Index (GHI) score is 28.7, child-wasting rate highest at 18.7. ● Gender inequality: India ranks 127 out of 146 nations in Global Gender Gap Report 2023; workforce “missing women” persist as a challenge. (Source – The Hindu Newspaper – January 16, 2024) Reasons for Growing Inequality: ● Economic Policies: Economic reforms and liberalisation policies have led to unequal distribution of wealth, with benefits accruing to the affluent while marginalised groups remain excluded. ● Urban-Rural Divide: Disparities between urban and rural areas in terms of access to resources, infrastructure, and opportunities exacerbate income inequality. ● Education Disparities: Unequal access to quality education perpetuates socio-economic disparities, limiting opportunities for upward mobility. ● Informal Sector: The dominance of the informal sector in India’s economy leads to low wages, precarious employment, and lack of social security, contributing to income inequality. ● Caste and Social Discrimination: Persistent caste-based discrimination and social hierarchies perpetuate inequalities, particularly affecting marginalised communities. ● Gender Disparities: Gender-based discrimination in education, employment, and wages results in lower incomes and limited economic opportunities for women, exacerbating inequality. ● Wealth Concentration: Concentration of wealth among a small elite contributes to widening income gaps and exacerbates socio-economic inequality. Implications of Growing Inequality: ● Social Unrest: Rising inequality can fuel social tensions, conflicts, and unrest, leading to instability and discord within society. ● Health Disparities: Inequality in access to healthcare leads to disparities in health outcomes, with marginalised communities suffering from higher rates of morbidity and mortality. ● Education Divide: Inequality in education perpetuates intergenerational poverty and limits social mobility, widening the gap between the rich and the poor. ● Political Instability: Growing inequality undermines democratic principles and can lead to political instability, populism, and erosion of social cohesion. ● Economic Growth: High levels of inequality can hinder economic growth and development by limiting human capital formation, productivity, and innovation. Way Forward: ● Progressive Taxation: Implement progressive tax policies to redistribute wealth and income, ensuring a more equitable distribution of resources. ● Investment in Education: Increase investment in education, particularly for marginalised communities, to improve access to quality education and enhance skills development. ● Social Protection: Strengthen social safety nets, welfare programs, and labour rights to provide support and protection for vulnerable populations. ● Gender Equality: Promote gender equality through policies and programs that empower women, eliminate discrimination, and ensure equal opportunities in education and employment. ● Inclusive Economic Growth: Foster inclusive economic growth by prioritising sectors that create employment opportunities, promote entrepreneurship, and reduce poverty. ● Land Reforms: Implement land reforms to address land ownership disparities and ensure access to land for landless farmers and marginalised communities. |
PYQ: COVID-19 pandemic accelerated class inequalities and poverty in India. Comment. (150 words/10m) (UPSC CSE (M) GS-1 2020) |
Practice Question: Discuss the implications of rising inequality in India and evaluate the effectiveness of proposed measures for wealth redistribution and inclusive growth. (150 Words /10 marks) |